Lawyers paradise - 7 years late, 3x the cost... and a city full of lawsuits

Published 3 months ago • 1 min read

Edinburgh, Scotland.
Mid-2000s.
A shiny new tram network was promised.
Fast, green, world-class transport across the city.

Greta was not born yet… but she could be smiling for ours to a project like this.

The vehicle?
Of course…

A complex PPP scheme led by Transport Initiatives Edinburgh (TIE) with multiple contractors, including Bilfinger Berger and Siemens.

Signed in 2006.
Cost? £375 million.
Opening date? 2011.

What actually happened?

Endless disputes between the public agency and the private contractors.
Construction delays so bad that people literally forgot the city was supposed to have trams.
Streets ripped up for years, paralyzing local businesses.
Costs ballooned to £1 billion — almost 3x the original.

Lawyers paradise… Who sued who?

Contractors sued the public agency for design changes and late payments.
The public agency threatened to sue the contractors for cost overruns and missed deadlines.
Residents and businesses started separate lawsuits over lost income and disturbance.

2014 — The first line finally opens.
Seven years late.
One single line instead of the full network.

The political fallout?

Heads rolled.
Public trust in PPPs collapsed.
Edinburgh became a punchline for bad project management across Europe.
Great was born… unhappy.

Brutal lessons:

If the project scope isn’t 100% locked before signing, you're building a time bomb.
Multi-contractor PPPs need wartime-grade governance, not PowerPoint slides.
Political wishful thinking kills delivery discipline.
Litigation isn't a risk; it’s a certainty when your contract is a mess.

Moral:
If your project needs seven years of excuses, lawsuits, and triple the money,
you didn’t build infrastructure.
You built a monument to failure.

I have other interesting and horror stories about my last project in the link below.

$99.90

The 15 Top Lessons of a PPP Project Nightmare

Learn about:
The number 1 killer of Projects
Why this was not going to be just "another construction project, mate"... Read more

Get those lessons now

PD 1: If you liked this email, don't keep it in secret and forward it to a friend. They will thank you enormously one day.

PD 2: If somebody has sent you this email and you want to receive emails like this yourself, visit vicentevalencia.com

PD 3: If you want unsubscribe, click the link below.

An Amazon wish list says more about you than you think

In New Zealand there is a survey about the infrastructure world going on. They ask you two questions: One: how important you think that it is to have a pipeline for decision makers? Answer: critical. Two: how good is the actual pipeline. Answer: useless. The reason is simple. The actual pipeline is a wish list. A list of projects that want to be built. That’s great. But where is the tracking about what is in the pipeline and what is actually being delivered? If that’s not there, there is no...

about 14 hours ago • 1 min read

PPP Review Procedures Are Not a Design-by-Committee Exercise

Today I had some conversations about one of the biggest sources of delay, frustration, and conflict in PPPs:The Review Procedures. Agencies still treat them like they’re signing a traditional construction contract. They micromanage the design. They dive into details they don’t own. And worst of all — they brief their consultants poorly (if at all) on what the review is supposed to achieve. The result? Endless comments that add no value. Delays that push the schedule back months. An...

1 day ago • 1 min read

Why not looking for shelter

A few birthdays this week. And you know what. People get older. Time passes by… but they do not necessarily grow up. As Robert Kiyosaki once said “Many people run from mom and dad’s shelter to the shelter of a company or the government”. Take government and you can exchange it by “a company”, “a secure job”, “a long term project”… Too many people spend their lives looking for guarantees and spend all their lives avoiding risk, avoiding growing up, and always looking for a surrogate “parent”...